We did a bunch of tasting tests and Skye loved the game :)
Here are the results:
Best of all:
Tuna and Salmon flaked, wet cat food (Wellness CORE)
Egg white (from our chickens)
Very close second. They are probably just a little bit lower because we used them more.
Tuna and Salmon Pate, wet cat food (Wellness CORE)
Beef sausages (Whole Foods)
Items she likes a lot:
Salmon skin (Trader Joe's)
Freeze dried beef liver (Pupford)
Salmon jerky (Trader Joe's)
Freeze dried salmon (Pupford)
Things she might eat if she feels like it, but of no value for training.
Vegan smoked salmon (Come Here Buddy)
Fish kibbles (Trader Joe's) - very low value
Salmon Sweet potato jerky (Trader Joe's) - no value
Beyond the items above we also can use the lick mat / kong with either vegan cream cheese or peanut butter. She really likes both.